The Surrogate Mother: A Thriller that Grips but Doesn’t Comfort

Written by Katie Barr

Freida McFadden’s The Surrogate Mother is a fast-paced, anxiety inducing psychological thriller that knows exactly how to keep readers turning the pages. With its sharp chapter breaks, spiralling paranoia, and all-too-relatable fear of not being believed, it delivers on the tension. And yet – despite its compelling premise and emotional weight – I found myself disconnected, waiting for it to be over. Not because it was badly written, but perhaps because it was too effective making me feel trapped in a world I didn’t want to stay in. 

Let’s start with the positives because there are many. McFadden clearly knows how to craft a gripping story. The concept of a surrogate whose life spirals out of control as secrets unravel and trust erodes is undeniably gripping. It’s a modern domestic nightmare, tapping into the deep discomfort of bodily autonomy, motherhood, and identity. The idea of someone being welcomed into a family and then slowly, terrifyingly, being pushed out – emotionally, psychologically, and possibly even physically – potent. There’s something uniquely disturbing about the idea that the people you’re supposed to trust the most are the ones orchestrating your downfall. That tension, the sense that something is off, but you can’t prove it, is where the book really shines. 

McFadden’s pacing is another strength. The short, punchy chapters are perfect for this genre.  I found myself saying ‘just one more’ and then burning through five. It’s compulsively readable. The constant forward motion keeps the suspense tight, and the writing flows easily. It’s clear McFadden understands the rhythm of psychological thrillers and how to manipulate the readers’ unease. 

Emotionally, the novel hits some real nerves. One of the most affecting aspects is the protagonist’s growing sense of isolation – how quickly people turn on her, how easily her version of events are dismissed. That fear of not being believed, of having your reality rewritten by those around you it’s even more disturbing. McFadden captures that particular kind of helplessness very well. It’s not loud or dramatic, it’s slow, creeping, suffocating. 

But here is where my ambivalence comes in: as effective as all of that was, this genre just didn’t sit well with me. I found myself emotionally exhausted, not in the cathartic way I enjoy from heavier fiction, but in a more agitated, uncomfortable way. Psychological thrillers often require the reader to live in a space of uncertainty and suspicion, and while this book executes that dynamic well, it didn’t offer me the emotional or intellectual payoff I was hoping for. I didn’t walk away from it feeling surprised or particularly moved, just unsettled and not in a satisfying way. 

In fact, I was ready for the book to be over about three quarters of the way in. That’s not necessarily a criticism of the writing – it might actually be a testament to how effectively McFadden creates a claustrophobic, stressful atmosphere. But when you’re more relieved to be finished than eager to reach the resolution, it speaks to a disconnect between the reader and the material. The anxiety was there but so was a certain emotional detachment. I wasn’t invested in the characters the way I wanted to be. 

And while the twists were fine, I didn’t find them especially shocking. There’s a certain formula at work, and although McFadden navigates it well, the beats felt familiar. I wouldn’t call the story predictable but I wouldn’t call it surprising either. It felt like it was walking the well-worn path of the domestic thriller genre without stepping too far off it. 

That said, I think readers who love these kinds of intense, paranoia-fuelled narratives will enjoy it far more than I did. If you’re someone who thrives on suspense, unreliable narrators, and the unravelling of seemingly perfect lives, this book absolutely delivers. It’s atmospheric, emotionally fraught, and just disturbing enough to get under your skin. It’s a well-written book with a strong concept, steady pacing, and enough emotional tension to keep the pages turning. 

My personal discomfort with the genre shaped my experience more than the novel’s quality did. It didn’t fail to grip me, it just didn’t reward that grip in the way I wanted. It’s one of those reads where I can recognise the craft, even if I didn’t love the experience. If you’re in the mood for a tense, claustrophobic domestic thriller, this one might be exactly what you’re looking for. Just don’t be surprised if it leaves you breathless, and a little bruised. 

 All content is original to The Literary Lounge.

In-article image courtesy of Good Reads and Julian Gentile on Unsplash. No changes were made to this image. 

Looking for more thoughtful book reviews, engaging literary features, and fun reading content? Be sure to follow us on Instagram for updates, behind-the-scenes peeks, and daily bookish inspiration.

If you’d like to share your thoughts, request a review, or collaborate with us, visit our Contact Page — we’d love to hear from fellow book lovers!